War of the Disks: A Close-in Analysis of the Hard Disk Drive vs. the Solid State Disk

Much has been written about solid state disks (SSDs)of HDDs a crucial point in technological purchases. The
becoming the next big thing1 in the IT industry(1). Buttypical access time for a Flash based SSD is about 35
as to whether or not we have enough knowledge of- 100 s, whereas that of a rotating disk is around
how it will revolutionize the industry is a different5,000 - 10,000 s. That makes a Flash-based SSD
question. How much do we really know about SSDs?approximately 100 times faster than a rotating disk.
If we are to ask people on the streets, it wouldn'tThis however raises another point - what's the
come as a surprise that they dont know much ofbenefit of a high-speed SSD when the entire system
what an SSD is. Even if they do know, mostcannot support it? The evolution of CPUs in terms of
probably it would be limited to a USB pen drive, aperformance has far surpassed the development of
CompactFlash or a Secure Digital card, which arethe data storage system. The HDD is actually limiting
more on the consumer side of the storage industry.the potential of a computer system when they are
Technically speaking, they are not wrong. Most webnot able to keep up with the performance of the
definitions describe an SSD as a high-performanceother components, particularly the CPU. If an HDD is
plug-and-play storage device that contains no movingreplaced by a high-speed SSD, the performance
parts. Therefore, given that most of thewould significantly improve. The resulting system
aforementioned mobile disk storage devices containwould be a high-powered set-up that can go beyond
no movable parts, they can certainly be categorizedthe demands of high-speed business or military
as SSDs.environments.
But then again, there's more to SSDs than being aSize Matters
non-volatile device. The purpose of this article is toTo be a true plug-in replacement for HDDs,
give readers a clearer picture of what an SSD is, itsFlash-based SSDs are manufactured in standard 2.5"
usage as well as its difference when pitted againstand 3.5" form factors. 2.5" SSDs are normally used in
the predominant data storage device at present -laptops or notebooks while the 3.5" form factors are
the hard disk drive (HDD). More than its non-volatility,used in desktops, or in JBOD or other SAN/NAS/DAS
this article will reveal how much potential SSDs haveconfigurations. They can often be used to replace
in optimizing the performance of the computingtraditional disks in storage arrays or in a server's
system.internal disk bays. Flash-based SSDs certainly fit the
SSD Definedstorage needs of most embedded systems that
Here are several ways the SSD is defined:require much smaller form factors.
"A solid state disk (SSD) is electrically, mechanicallyReliability
and software compatible with a conventionalIn terms of reliability, conventional HDDs pale when
(magnetic) hard disk or winchester. The difference iscompared to SSDs. The absence of mechanical arms
that the storage medium is not magnetic (like a hardand spinning platters is the reason behind its reliability.
disk) or optical (like a CD) but solid stateIn demanding environments, SSDs provide the type
semiconductor such as battery backed RAM, EPROMof ruggedness required for mobile applications. Unlike
or other electrically erasable RAM-like chip. Thisthe HDD, SSD's can withstand extreme shock and
provides faster access time than a disk, because thevibration with data integrity and without any danger
data can be randomly accessed and does not rely onof data loss. This feature is very important in
a read/write interface head synchronising with aindustrial applications where exposure to highly
rotating disk. The SSD also provides greater physicalcombustible materials and electromagnetic radiation
resilience to physical vibration, shock and extremeare typical. Their ability to deliver unnerving
temperature fluctuations. The only downside is aperformance in extreme conditions also makes SSD
higher cost per megabyte of storage."(2)play a vital role in military operations, be it in defense,
"Abbreviated SSD, a solid state disk is aaerospace or aviation applications. Military applications
high-performance plug-and-play storage device thatrequire, in most cases, an operating temperature
contains no moving parts. SSD components includerange of -60°C to +95°C. Shock, vibration,
either DRAM or flash memory boards, a memory busand temperature ratings of HDDs cannot comply with
board, a CPU, and a battery card. Because theymilitary standards, only SSDs can.
contain their own CPUs to manage data storage,Power Play
they are a lot faster (18MBps for SCSI-II and 44In addition to speed, reliability and mortality rate being
MBps for UltraWide SCSI interfaces) thanpositively affected by the SSD's non-volatility, they
conventional rotating hard disks ; therefore, theyalso consume much less power than traditional HDDs.
produce highest possible I/O rates. SSDs are mostNo additional power is required to activate the
effective for server applications and server systems,platters or the mechanical arms present in most
where I/O response time is crucial. Data stored onHDDs. Its power consumption is practically only a
SSDs should include anything that createsfraction of a hard disk drive.
bottlenecks, such as databases, swap files, library andHeat Dissipation
index files, and authorization and login information."(3)Along with the lower power consumption, there is
For the rest of the article, we will compare the HDDsalso much lesser heat dissipation for systems using
and Flash-based SSDs. The latter are the mostFlash-based SSDs as their data storage solution. This
popular type of SSDs employed by the military,is due to the absence of heat generated from the
aerospace, industrial and embedded systemsrotating/movable media. This certainly proves to be
industries.the one of the main advantages of Flash-based SSDs
Mortality Raterelative to that of a traditional HDD. With less heat
Hard disk failure is a common occurrence in this agedissipation, it serves as the ideal data storage solution
of desktops and notebooks. A lot of horror storiesfor mobile systems such as PDAs, notebooks, etc.
have been told, passed around and even publishedUsers can do away with large cooling fans, internal
about how valuable data was lost and the agony ofpower supply and batteries for large storage arrays
trying to retrieve or at least save a portion of thein storage area networks.
crashed hard drive. It is during this time that peopleCost Considerations
wonder, why do hard disks fail?Of course, everything comes with a price. Based on
The reason is simple - wear and tear. Just like anya cost-benefit logic, it is but expected that something
good old machine with mechanical components, HDDswith very impressive features be priced higher than
tend to deteriorate over time. HDDs consist ofsomething that offers fewer benefits. SSDs as being
rotating, magnetically coated disks, known asa bit more pricey than the traditional hard disk drive
platters, that are used to store data. This rotatingmay be one of the compelling reasons why up to
motion of the mechanical arms results in much wearnow it hasn't gained as much popularity as it should
and tear after long periods of use. The operationalbe getting with all its brilliant functions.
lifespan of a computer HDD is over three years.(4)While the use of SSDs today have mostly been
A Flash-based SSD is different. Although the mostlimited to industrial and military implications, enterprise
common Flash chips have around 300,000 writeare now looking closely at SSDs for implementing
cycles, the best Flash chips are rated at 1,000,000tiered storage and optimizing their storage
write cycles per block. On top of that, Flash SSDarchitectures.
manufacturers employ different ways to increase theTo quote from the Solid State Disks Buyers Guide
longevity of the drives. In some cases, they use apublished by storagesearch.com, "In fact the SSD is
"balancing" algorithm to monitor the number of timesreplacing servers and software licenses. SSDs can be
each disk block has been written, which greatlyused either to speed up the response time of
extends the operational lifespan of the drive.existing applications as an alternative to buying more
Furthermore, these manufacturers also designedservers, or to reduce the number of servers and
special "wear-leveling" algorithms where once asoftware licenses deployed. The economics can be
certain percentage threshold for a given block iscompellingly in favor of an SSD deployment". The
reached, the SSD will swap the data in that blockindustry is also expecting more breakthroughs as
with the data in another block that has exhibited ahigher memory capacities and faster performance are
"read-only-like" characteristic in the background. Thisnow being produced for a wider array of choices fit
reduces performance lag and avoids further wearingfor any mission-critical application.
off of the blocks and thrashing of the disk. Even withAnalysts foresee a rapidly closing gap between HDD
usage patterns of writing/reading gigabytes per day,and flash SSD pricing (see related article "Are Flash
a Flash-based SSD should last several years,Solid-State Disks Ready for the Enterprise"(5) ). This
depending on its capacity. Add to that the inclusion ofvision is also bolstered by a recent announcement(6)
a DRAM cache in the disk architecture that furtherof electronic giant Samsung that they will invest
enhances its operational capabilities as well as lifespan.heavily in improving their flash and DRAM production
Speeding Uplines and flash SSD equipped laptops. Only time will tell
With the very fast paced lifestyle these days, mostif we will witness widespread commercial adoption of
businesses are time-bound and cannot afford aSSDs.
slowing down in their transactions. This makes speed